PODCAST
Synthetic vs. Organic Approaches in the Sustainability of Athletic Fields: II. Effects on Soil Properties and Soil Health
PODCAST: PLAY IN NEW WINDOW | DOWNLOAD
SUBSCRIBE: APPLE PODCASTS | SPOTIFY
Welcome to The Turf Zone podcast. This episode features the article “Synthetic vs. Organic Approaches in the Sustainability of Athletic Fields: II. Effects on Soil Properties and Soil Health” written by Dr. William M. Dest and Dr. J. Scott Ebdon.
Read from New England Blade magazine.
Study Objectives
Continuous applications of natural organic fertilizers potentially improve soil health by increasing soil fertility and organic matter. Changes to various soil chemical properties (nutrient content), physical properties (soil bulk density, soil aggregate stability) and biological properties (total soil carbon) when using natural organic fertilizers could potentially influence overall microbial activity and plant health.
Long-term comparisons over several years between organic and synthetic management were previously discussed in New England Blade (Fall 2026 issue). Clear benefits in terms of better traffic (wear) tolerance were demonstrated when using synthetic fertilizers and conventional management over organic (natural) fertilizers. In this episode, synthetic and organic management effects on soil properties and soil health under eight years of simulated traffic are presented. The results presented here are a summary of previously published (peer-reviewed) studies by the authors (Dest and Ebdon, 2025).
Study Area
The study was established in 2010 on Kentucky bluegrass (KBG) sod at the Troll Turf Center, South Deerfield MA (University of Massachusetts – Amherst). The soil is a native silt loam with a sand, silt, and clay content of 24.4, 66.6, and 9.0%, respectively, and soil organic matter (SOM) content of 2.7%. The sod was inter-seeded yearly in combination with simulated traffic and aeration practices.
Simulated traffic (wear) using the D.S.1 traffic simulator (Canaway, 1976) was fall applied weekly from 2010 to 2017.
The total traffic applied yearly using the simulator was equivalent to 24 soccer games in the center areas-high wear areas (Canaway, 1981). A blend of turf-type perennial ryegrasses (PRG) seeded at a rate of 7 lb./1000ft² and a blend of KBG at 2 lb./1000ft² were applied with simulated traffic to cleat-in seed.
Synthetic or organic management practices were main plots. Main plots were split as subplots according to height of cut (HOC, 1.25 inch mowed with reel mowers 2 to 3 times weekly and 2.5 inch mowed once weekly with rotary mowers). Approximately ¼ of the subplots received wear treatments.
Synthetic practices included yearly chemical fertilizers and pesticides. Hand-weeding, biological fertilizers (leaf compost and naturally derived organics) with biological controls (corn gluten, parasitic nematodes) were used in the organic plots. Both approaches received the same yearly N of 4 lb./1000ft². Fertilizer P2O5 varied with the N source because of the low N content (high product spread rate) of the organic sources. Organic plots received 1.1 lb. P₂O₅/1000ft²/yr compared to 0.36 lb. P₂O₅ for synthetic.
Rotational Traction – Results
Rotational traction was measured using a device described by Canaway and Bell (1986). The device comprised a 6-inch steel disc with six football studs spaced at intervals around the disc. The disc was weighted with 75 lb. plates and dropped from a 6-inch height so that the studs fully penetrated the surface. The torque required for the studs to tear (break) the surface was measured and is reported as Nm (Newton-meter). Four measurements were taken in September on wear treated plots and then averaged.
Traction ranged from 39 to 64 Nm; which are above the minimum standard of 25 to 35 Nm (Aldous, 1999; Canaway et al., 1990). Traction readings above 70 Nm are reported by players in surveys as unsatisfactorily high (Aldous et al., 2005). Rotational traction values of 25 to 55 Nm are preferred by players. In our study rotational traction values were consistent with player preferences.
In a survey conducted by Dest and Ebdon (2011) involving 12 high school and college athletic fields, they reported an average traction in the soccer field-center areas (goal-to-goal) to be 39.8 Nm with a range of 28.8 to 48.3 Nm. Our overall average traction of 50.8 Nm is approximately 28% higher than the survey average suggesting slightly better traction for the athlete under the simulated traffic conditions of our study. Traction measured in these studies were conducted using the same device
Repeated overseeding with PRG into KBG sod under traffic is likely changing the stand composition from KBG to predominantly PRG (Dest et al., 2009). Generally the lower (1.25-inch) HOC exhibited twice the turf density under traffic than 2.5-inch HOC (32 vs. 17 shoots/inch²). Better traction is often observed with greater grass cover under traffic (Dest et al., 2009; Holmes and Bell, 1986).
Organic and synthetic management practices exhibited no difference in traction (50.6 vs. 51.0 Nm, respectively). Height of cut affected traction (Table 1) depending on the year. Traction at the 1.25-inch HOC was 10% higher during three of the eight years evaluated (2013, 2014, 2016) while during the first year (2010) traction was observed to be 20% higher at the taller HOC (2.5-inch). For traction values above the 55 Nm threshold, only 3 of 16 traction values would be categorized as non-preferred by players.
The higher density under traffic at the lower HOC (1.25-inch) is the principal reason for the better wear tolerance observed at the lower HOC; which was discussed in the previous episode. Organic and synthetic management practices afforded identical turf densities (25 shoots/inch²) and therefore were similar in rotational traction afforded to athletes.
Soil pH and Soil Available Phosphorus –
Results
In 2010, 2013 to 2017 soil samples were taken (three per plot) to a depth of 3.0 inches to measure soil pH and soil available P (ppm). Soil pH was measured in a soil-to-water ratio of 1:1 with a glass electrode and soil available P was measured using the modified Morgan procedures. Measurements were made in September before fall fertilization and overseeding.
Generally, as years progressed, soil pH declined with years (r = –586, p ≤ .001, n = 96). Under synthetic management using urea (as SCU) and strongly acidifying ammonium-sulfur based fertilizers such as ammonium sulfate (21–0–0), soil pH declined by 0.85 pH units with year. Only a 0.5 pH unit drop was observed in eight years using organic based fertilizers applied as leaf compost (1.1–0.5–0), corn gluten (9–0–0), and plant-animal residue (8–3–5).
Except for one year (2014), organic management was consistently higher in soil pH (above 6.0). The more favorable soil pH (above 6.0) in the case of organic practices potentially eliminates the need for lime applications and is one of the benefits to turf managers to using the organic approach compared to synthetic practices.
Despite repeated use of leaf composts over eight years (equivalent to 730 lb./1000ft²), soil available P was never an environmental concern based on final soil P levels under organic management. The organic system highest soil available P level of 26.5 ppm is considered slightly above optimum using the modified Morgan procedure. That said, there is the possibility of a negative impact to turf and to the environment if P containing fertilizers are added. As such, fertilizing sites testing above the optimum should be avoided by not applying P containing fertilizers (Bierman et al., 2010).
When compared to 16 ppm of soil available P measured in non-fertilized areas, synthetic plots increased by only 18% (to 18.8 ppm) whereas organic plots increased in soil available P by as much as 66% (to 26.5 ppm). Compared to the synthetic program, there may be a stronger case for more regular soil testing for available P with repeated applications of organic amendments to turfgrass soils.
Soil Health – Results
Predominantly silty soils (i.e., Troll Turf Center silt loam) form aggregates (secondary structure) that are less stable. As a measure of resistance of soil structure to mechanical, wind or water breakdown, soil aggregate stability (SAG, %) was measured from years 2013 to 2017. Optimal aggregate stability requires the frequent input of fresh organic matter residues typical of organic programs.
Composted leaf materials applied annually at 91 lb. per 1000ft² as used in our study, has the potential to increase aggregate stability because of the binding abilities of SOM. Traffic increases soil bulk densities (i.e., soil compaction tendencies). Better soil stability has the potential to lower soil bulk densities (BD) under traffic.
A biologically active soil containing SOM and its close relative, soil organic carbon (SOC), are more predisposed to aggregate stability (Watts et al. 2001). To that end, SOC was measured during the fall (2015 to 2017) from three soil samples using high temperature combustion (1100°C) methods and SOM was measured from loss on ignition in 2010 and 2013 to 2017.
Organic management promoted 25% more SOM compared to synthetic practices based on overall means (synthetic vs. organic, 3.2 vs. 4.0%, respectively. As years progressed, SOM increased (r = 0.469, p ≤ .001, n = 96), especially under organic practices (r = 0.691, p ≤ 0.001, n = 48) compared to the synthetic approach (r = 0.369, p = 0.027, n = 48). Generally, SOM is positively correlated with the age of the turf system as continuous growth and death of turfgrass roots and other plants tissues contribute to SOM (Cheng et al., 2008; Petrovic, 1990; Sapkota et al., 2020).
Previous research supports the notion of limiting organic matter to avoid the loss in macropores, decrease infiltration, and the loss in wear tolerance and surface hardness (Baker et al., 2001; Carrow, 1998, 2004a, 2004b). Carrow (1998, 2004a, 2004b) found surface organic matter accumulation beyond 3.0 to 5.0% can be problematic under traffic. Our measured SOM for both organic and synthetic practices are consistent with SOM thresholds recommended by Carrow.
Compared to synthetic management, soil aggregate stability increased by 10% with organic practices along with 20% higher SOM, 15% higher SOC and 6% higher soil pH. The organic approach has the potential to promote greater soil aggregation and stability under the repeated mechanical stresses of the traffic simulator used in our study.
The greatest benefits to resisting breakdown in soil structure under traffic was most apparent in the last year of our eight-year study (2017) when soil aggregate stability was 75% higher with organic practices (24.6%) compared to synthetic management (14.0%). Like SOM), soil aggregate stability develops slowly over time and the effects are not immediate.
Generally, in short term studies (i.e., 2-years), no difference between organic and synthetic practices are observed in SOM or soil bulk densities. Further evidence to the benefits of SOM and the additions of organic material to turfgrass soils is the lower soil bulk densities observed under simulated traffic indicating lower soil compaction tendencies.
Soil BD for the Troll Turf Center silt loam under no traffic was 1.16 g cm⁻³ compared to 1.23 and 1.28 g cm⁻³ observed under traffic for organic and synthetic practices, respectively. Additions of organic material to turfgrass soils lower soil bulk density by increasing SOM, which dilutes soil mineral matter (Bero and Soldat, 2022; Cogger, 2005; Dest and Ebdon, 2011; Sapkota et al., 2020).
Organic practices used in this study such as leaf composts and organic fertilizers enhanced both SOM and SAG more than synthetic practices that rely solely on recycling of grass clippings, all of which contribute to SOM formation (Strom et al., 1992).
What We’ve Learned – Organic vs. Synthetic
In most years, organic practices were associated with better soil health as the result of higher (favorable) soil pH, 20% higher soil available P, 25% higher soil organic matter, and lower soil bulk density under traffic compared to synthetic practices. Organic management also increased soil health by increasing aggregate stability under eight years of simulated traffic especially in the last year of the test. The benefits to amending turfgrass soils with organic materials is a slow process.
Results of this study and our companion study suggests competing benefits. Synthetic practices provide better wear tolerance while organic practices promote better soil health. A properly implemented best management approach combining synthetic and organic practices may be an appropriate option, which has been successful in reducing pesticide use in golf (Rossi and Grant, 2007).
References
Aldous, D.E. (1999). International turf management handbook. Dep. of Environ. Hortic. and Res. Manage., Univ. of Melbourne, VIC, Australia, and CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL.
Aldous, D. E., Chivers, I.H., and Kerr, R. (2005). Player perceptions of Australian Football League grass surfaces. Int. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J. 10(Part 1):p. 318-324.Association of American Plant Food Control Officials. (2017). Official publication. AAPFCO, West Lafayette, IN.
Baker, S. W., Binns, D.J., Cook, A., and Mooney, S.J. (2001). The performance of cricket pitches in relation to soil type and moisture content. Int. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J. 9(Part 2):p. 469-478.
Bero, N. J., and Soldat, D.J. (2022). Effect of topdressing of compost, compost tea, and various fertilizers on soil and lawn characteristics. Int. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J., 14, 110-120.
Bierman, P. M., Horgan, B.P., Rosen, C.J., Hollman, A.B., and Pagliari, P.H. (2010). Phosphorus runoff from turfgrass as affected by phosphorus fertilization and clipping management. J. Environ. Qual. 39, 282-292.
Canaway, P.M. (1976). A differential slip wear machine (D.S.1.) for the artificial simulation of turfgrass wear. J. Sports Turf Res. Inst., 52, 82-99.
Canaway, P. M. (1981). A comparison of real and artificial wear. J. Sports Turf Res. Inst., 57, 108-121.
Canaway, P.M., and Bell, M.J. (1986). Technical note: An apparatus for measuring traction and friction on natural and artificial playing surfaces. J. Sports Turf Res. Inst., 62, 211-214.
Canaway, P. M., Bell, M. J., Holmes, G., and Baker, S. W. (1990). Standards for the playing quality of natural turf for association football. In R. C. Schmidt, E. F. Hoerner, E. M. Milner, & C. A. Morehouse (Eds.), Natural and artificial playing fields: Characteristics and safety features (pp. 29–47). Philadelphia, PA: American Society for Testing and Materials. https://doi.org/10.1520/STP25 347S
Carrow, R. (1998). Organic matter dynamics in the surface zone of a USGA green: practices to alleviate problems. In 1998 Turfgrass and Environmental Research Summary, USGA, Far Hills, N.J.
Carrow, R.N. (2004a). Surface organic matter in creeping bentgrass greens. Golf Course Management 72(5):96-101.
Carrow, R.N. (2004b). Surface organic matter in bermudagrass greens: A primary stress? Golf Course Management. 72(5):102-105.
Cheng, Z., Richmond. D.S, Salminen, S.O, and Grewal, P.S. (2008). Ecology of urban lawns under three common management programs. Urban Ecosyst.11:177–195 DOI 10.1007/s11252-008-0048-9
Cogger, C. G. (2005). Potential compost benefits for restoration of soils disturbed by urban development. Compost Science and Utilization, 13(4), 243–251. https://doi.org/10.1080/1065657X.2005.10702248
Dest, W.M., Ebdon, J.S., and Guillard, K. (2009). Differentiating between the influence of wear and soil compaction and their interaction of turfgrass stress. Int. Turf. Soc. Res. J., 11, 1067– 1083.
Dest, W.M., and Ebdon, J.S. (2011). Study: Natural turf use levels. Sports Turf Magazine. Study: Natural turf use levels | SportsField Management (sportsfieldmanagementonline.com)
Dest, W. M., and Ebdon, J. S. (2025). Sustainability of athletic field turf comparing organic and synthetic practices under two heights of cut. Crop Science, 65, e21317. https://doi.org/10.1002/csc2.21317
Holmes, G., and Bell, M. J. (1986). Playing surface hardness and tennis ball rebound resilience. Journal of the Sports Turf Research Institute, 62, 207–210.
Petrovic, A.M. (1990). The fate of nitrogenous fertilizers applied to turfgrass. Environ Qual. 19:1–14.
Rossi, F. S., and Grant, J.A. (2009). Long term evaluation of reduced chemical pesticide management of golf course putting turf. Int. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J. 11, 77-90.
Sapkota, M., Young, J., Coldren, C., Slaughter, L., and Longing, S. (2020). Soil physiochemical properties and carbon sequestration of urban landscapes in Lubbock, TX, USA. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening. 56, 44203. DOI: 10.1016/j.ufug.2020.126847
Strom, P.F., Murphy, J.A., and Indyk, H.W. (1992). Minimizing waste disposal: grass clippings. Rutgers cooperative research & extension fact sheet (Publication Number FS389). Full-text Pdf Available upon request.
Watts C.W., Whalley, W.R., Longstaff, D.J., White, R.P., Brookes, P.C., and Whitmore, A.P. (2001). Aggregation of a soil with different cropping histories following the addition of organic materials. Soil Use and Management 17, 263-268.
You have been listening to The Turf Zone Podcast. Follow The Turf Zone on X, Facebook and LinkedIn for all things turfgrass, featuring podcasts, magazines, events and more.
READ THE ISSUE
