LATEST PODCAST
Synthetic vs. Organic Approaches in the Sustainability of Athletic Fields: I. Effects on Wear Tolerance and Ball Bounce
PODCAST: PLAY IN NEW WINDOW | DOWNLOAD
SUBSCRIBE: APPLE PODCASTS | SPOTIFY
Welcome to The Turf Zone podcast. This episode features the article “Synthetic vs. Organic Approaches in the Sustainability of Athletic Fields: I. Effects on Wear Tolerance and Ball Bounce” written by Dr. William M. Dest and Dr. J. Scott Ebdon. Read from New England Blade magazine.
Author’s Note
The research summarized here was the final research conducted by Dr. Bill Dest before his death in April 2021. A man of great academic curiosity, Dr. Dest was also a great mentor to many students. This work was published after his death (Dest and Ebdon, 2025) and spanned an 8-year period (2010 to 2017).
Due to environmental concerns, there has been increased interest in organic practices. Long-term comparisons over several years (i.e., sustainability) between organic and synthetic approaches is lacking in sports turf research. To that end, this research compared organic (natural) land care practices for athletic and recreational fields with synthetic practices that rely on pesticides and standard (synthetic) fertilizers. Player safety (surface hardness) and plant health (wear tolerance) are summarized below. Also, soccer ball bounce was studied comparing two heights of cut – 1.25 inch (elite athletic fields) and 2.5 inch (municipal recreational fields). Soil health properties (soil organic matter, soil bulk density, soil aggregate stability) were also investigated but are not discussed here.
Study area and simulated traffic
The study was established on Kentucky bluegrass (KBG) sod at the Troll Turf Center, South Deerfield MA (University of Massachusetts – Amherst). The soil was a native silt loam with a sand, silt and clay composition of 24.4, 66.6, and 9.0%, respectively, and soil organic matter (SOM) content of 2.7%. The sod was inter-seeded yearly in combination with simulated traffic and aeration practices. Wear was fall applied weekly each year using a differential slip wear machine (D.S.1, Canaway, 1976) fitted with steel football-soccer cleats. A blend of turf-type perennial ryegrasses (PRG) seeded at a rate of 7 lb./1000ft² and a blend of KBG at 2 lb./1000ft² were inter-seeded during simulated traffic to cleat-in the seed.
Plots received weekly wear irrespective of the weather. Generally, 12 passes were made over all plots each time wear was imposed. Main plots (14 × 14 ft) with three (3) replicates consisted of synthetic or organic management practices. Main plots were split as subplots (7 × 7 ft) according to height of cut (HOC, 1.25 inch mowed with reel mowers 2 to 3 times weekly and 2.5 inch mowed once weekly with rotary mowers). Approximately ¼ of the subplots received wear treatments.
Organic and synthetic practices
Fertilization of synthetic and organic management systems is shown in. Leaf compost (~1.1% N, 0.2% P) (New England Organics, Photo 3) and corn gluten (9-0-0) (Harrington’s Organic Land Care) were generally applied within one to two weeks of each other. Organic 8-0.9-3.3 (N-P-K) (Sustane, 7.2% water insoluble N from aerobically composted turkey litter, feather meal) was applied with aeration and overseeding. These organic fertilization practices were repeated throughout the study. Leaf compost in the fall was raked into plots following core aeration in association with overseeding.
The synthetic managed plots followed the same basic schedule using a complete fertilizer (25-1.3-8.3, N-P-K) (25% as SRN from coated urea-N). In the early fall 21-0-0 (100% water soluble N from ammonium sulfate) was used during overseeding and aeration.
Pest management
Heavy overseeding used in this study was effective in suppressing broadleaf weeds in wear treated plots (Gannett et al., 2021). Synthetic plots were treated with conventional insecticides and pre- and post-emergent herbicides. Weed removal by hand from organic plots was necessary to prevent the ingress of weeds from compromising the plots as observed in previous studies (Brosnan et al., 2014; Miller and Henderson, 2013).
Organically managed plots received an application of corn gluten meal for early-season crabgrass control at a rate of 11.2 lb./1000ft² (Christians, 1993). In some years any crabgrass escape was removed by hand in the organic plots. Organic plots were treated with parasitic nematodes (Heterorhabditis bacteriophora) for annual white grubs control.
Soccer ball bounce (BB) and surface hardness
Surface hardness was measured using a Clegg Impact Soil Tester (Clegg, 1976). A 2.25 kg missile was dropped from a height of 30 cm with surface hardness measured as gravities (g). Four measurements were taken in September on wear treated plots and then averaged. Different locations were used for the hardness measurements. Hardness was measured during the same week and in all years as ball bounce.
Wear tolerance decreased as the number of years under traffic (wear) progressed. Wear injury was greatest by the 7th (2016) and 8th year (2017) of the test. Even with repeated aeration-overseeding, heavy-simulated traffic used in this study caused a progressive decline in wear tolerance from 6.1 (2010) to 3.8 (2017) based on yearly averages. Under these intensely trafficked conditions, other practices including the redistribution of traffic, water management, and resodding may be required in addition to overseeding to maintain acceptable grass cover.
Both the organic and synthetic practices were maintained under identical annual N rates (4 lb./1000ft²) and overseeding practices. That said, in 5 of 8 years the synthetic management program was statistically better than organic practices and afforded acceptable wear tolerance in 4 of 8 years compared to only one year of acceptable wear tolerance for the organic approach.
The lower HOC (1.25 inch) was statistically better than the taller HOC during the early years of the study (2010 to 2014) while during the later years (2015 to 2017) no difference was observed between HOC. In addition, the lower HOC was acceptable in overall wear tolerance in all years except the later years (2016 and 2017) while the taller HOC (2.5 inch) never afforded acceptable tolerance to traffic.
Trafficked plots fully recovered by spring (April and May) following fall overseeding and exhibited recovery from wear with ratings greater than 8. If the objective is better traffic (wear) tolerance, the synthetic management system and closer HOC (typical of elite sports fields) are preferred to the organic approach and taller HOC (typical of municipal-recreational fields).
As the hours of use per year increased, turf density decreased indicated by the lower wear tolerance ratings. The loss in turf density has been shown to relate to an increase in player-to-surface injuries. In a survey of 12 high school and collegian sports fields in New England, 15% of the injuries recorded by athletic trainers in soccer and American football were attributed to the lack of grass cover caused by traffic (Dest and Ebdon, 2011).
Ball bounce (BB) and surface hardness – Results
No significant effect was observed between synthetic and organic practices on BB or surface hardness. Taller (2.5-inch) HOC grass generally exhibited softer surfaces and lower BB. As years progressed soccer ball bounce decreased with surface hardness. Surface hardness in the study ranged from 36 to 63 gravities and BB ranged from 28% (2.7 ft BB) to 43% (4.2 ft BB).
The largest differential occurred in 2014 when a 20-inch (1.7 ft) higher BB and 12 gravities greater hardness was observed at the lower 1.25-inch HOC. In our study, a strong (positive) correlation (r = 0 .627, p ≤ .001, n = 96) was observed between soccer BB and surface hardness. For both approved tennis balls and soccer balls, the vertical height of the bounce is known to increase with increasingly harder surfaces (Ebdon and Buras, 2026).
According to Baker (1999), most professional soccer players (United Kingdom) prefer BB values between 30% (2.9 ft BB) to 45% (4.4 ft BB) with a preferred BB for amateur play of 20% (2 ft BB) to 50% (4.9 ft BB). Hardness values according to surveys of approximately 2000 Australian football players indicated that preferred hardness values ranged between 55 to 70 g using the 2.25 kg Clegg (Aldous et al., 2005). In general, players prefer to fall on ground that have hardness values below 105 gravities.
In the same survey by Dest and Ebdon (2011) they also reported the average hardness of soccer field-center areas (goal-to-goal) to be 55.8 gravities. Their survey of surface hardness is measured in the center areas at the end of the football, soccer or lacrosse playing seasons and is similar to our observed hardness values. It’s important to recognize that our measurement of surface hardness is based on controlled-simulated traffic equivalent to 24 soccer games typical of the center circle.
Interestingly, we found soccer BB on shorter 1.25-inch HOC grass when mowed 2 to 3 times per week to be as much as 1.7-ft higher in BB but also 70% more uniform-consistent (less variable from bounce-to-bounce) than mowing once per week at the 2.5-inch HOC. Generally, as surface hardness increases, the uniformity-consistency of BB is also observed to increase (Ebdon and Buras, 2026).
Study findings after eight years
When traffic (wear) tolerance is the priority for turf managers, then the synthetic program offers a major advantage over the organic approach. In most years shorter cut grass (1.25-inch) consistently provided better wear tolerance, higher and more uniform ball bounce than taller cut grass (2.5-inch).
Both organic and synthetic management systems provided surface hardness and ball bounce values consistent with player preferences. As part of this same study, the organic management approach offers other benefits over synthetic management such as better soil health; which will be discussed in a future episode.
References
Aldous, D. E., Chivers, I.H., and Kerr, R. (2005). Player perceptions of Australian Football League grass surfaces. Int. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J. 10(Part 1):p. 318-324.Association of American Plant Food Control Officials. (2017). Official publication. AAPFCO, West Lafayette, IN.
Baker, S.W. (1999). The playing quality of turfgrass sports surfaces. P. 231-244. In D.E. Aldous (Ed.) International Turf Management Handbook, Chapter 14, Butterworth-Heinemann.
Brosnan, J.T., Dickson, K.H., Sorochan, J.C., Thoms, A.W., and Stier, J.C. (2014). Large crabgrass, white clover, and hybrid bermudagrass athletic field playing quality in response to simulated traffic. Crop Sci., 54,1838–1843.
Canaway, P.M. (1976). A differential slip wear machine (D.S.1.) for the artificial simulation of turfgrass wear. J. Sports Turf Res. Inst., 52, 82–99.
Canaway, P. M. (1981). A comparison of real and artificial wear. J. Sports Turf Res. Inst., 57, 108-121.
Christians, N.E. (1993). The use of corn gluten meal as a natural preemergence weed control in turf. Intl. Turfgrass Soc. Res. J., 7, 284–290.
Clegg, B. (1976). An impact testing device for in situ base course evaluation. Australia Road Res. Bur. Proc. 5, 1-6.
Dest, W.M., and Ebdon, J.S. (2011). Study: Natural turf use levels. Sports Turf Magazine. Study: Natural turf use levels | SportsField Management (sportsfieldmanagementonline.com)
Dest, W. M., and Ebdon, J. S. (2025). Sustainability of athletic field turf comparing organic and synthetic practices under two heights of cut. Crop Science, 65, e21317. https://doi.org/10.1002/csc2.21317
Ebdon, S., and M. Buras. (2026). Anyone for tennis – research?. New England Blade. p. 14-16, 18-19.
Gannett, M., Bray, N. Lampman, J., Lerner, J., Murray, K., Wallace, V., et al. (2021). Repetitive overseeding for ecological management of grass playing fields. HortScience, 56, 226-233.
Miller, N. A., and Henderson, J.J. (2013). The effects on playing surface characteristics and soil physical properties. Crop Sci., 53, 637-646.
You have been listening to The Turf Zone Podcast. Follow The Turf Zone on X, Facebook and LinkedIn for all things turfgrass, featuring podcasts, magazines, events and more.
READ THE ISSUE
